India’s military history has often been told through the rise and fall of empires, the outcome of battles and the decisions of rulers.
But what if the more enduring story lies elsewhere – in the resilience of ordinary people, the preservation of civilisational memory and a military tradition that has evolved through centuries of conflict?
That is the central argument of Colonel (Dr) DPK Pillay (Retd), decorated Indian Army veteran and military scholar, in his book India at War: Empires, Battles and the Making of a Nation.
In an exclusive interview, Pillay challenges the long-standing proposition that India lacked an indigenous strategic culture, an argument associated with American scholar George Tanham’s 1992 essay on Indian strategic thought.
Pillay argues that this assessment reflects an external understanding of what constitutes strategic culture. Western interpretations, he says, tend to measure military success through territorial gains and battlefield outcomes. India’s historical experience, however, must also be understood through its ability to preserve its civilisational inheritance despite successive invasions, political upheavals and foreign domination.
For Pillay, the continuity of India as a living civilisation, despite centuries of disruption, is itself evidence of strategic resilience.
He also questions how colonial scholarship shaped Indian perceptions of their own history. British historians and administrators, he argues, promoted narratives of Indian inferiority and fragmentation that helped legitimise colonial rule. These interpretations subsequently became embedded in the country’s understanding of its past.
Another important theme in the book is the role of ordinary people in nation-building. Pillay argues that military history should not be confined to soldiers and rulers. Artisans, thinkers, religious reformers and communities that preserved cultural traditions were equally important in sustaining the idea of India.
The conversation brings this argument alive through the Battle of Haifa in 1918, when Indian cavalry units, including forces from Jodhpur, Mysore and Hyderabad, played a decisive role in the capture of the Ottoman-held city. Pillay recalls how the contribution of Indian soldiers was far better recognised in Israel than at home. He also describes efforts to bring the battle into India’s national consciousness, including its inclusion in Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s 2017 visit to Israel.
The discussion takes a more contentious turn when it examines India’s military and political decisions after Independence. Pillay is sharply critical of the handling of the 1947-48 Kashmir conflict, particularly the decision to approach the United Nations while Indian forces were advancing. He also questions whether India translated its decisive military victory in 1971 into commensurate diplomatic gains.
His assessment is blunt: “In 47-48, we snatched victory from the jaws of defeat. In 71, we snatched defeat from the jaws of victory.”
Yet Pillay’s understanding of military strength is not simply about the application of force. Drawing on his experience in Manipur, he emphasises the moral obligations of soldiers, particularly towards civilians and children caught in conflict. He argues that the purpose of military operations must ultimately be to restore trust and bring people back into the mainstream, with force remaining a last resort.
The interview also explores India’s contribution to the Korean War, where the 60 Parachute Field Ambulance provided medical assistance and India played an important diplomatic role in securing an armistice. Pillay recounts how Indian medical personnel treated the wounded without distinction, while Indian diplomacy helped bridge differences over prisoner repatriation.
For Pillay, these episodes reveal something distinctive about India’s military tradition: its capacity to combine courage with restraint, and military capability with a larger responsibility towards society.
The conversation ultimately raises a question that extends well beyond the book: has India adequately understood, documented and recognised the military and civilisational experiences that helped make it a nation?
In a career spanning three decades and counting, I’ve been the foreign editor of The Telegraph, Outlook Magazine and the New Indian Express. I helped set up rediff.com’s editorial operations in San Jose and New York, helmed sify.com, and was the founder editor of India.com. My work has featured in national and international publications like the Al Jazeera Centre for Studies, Global Times and Ashahi Shimbun. My one constant over all these years, however, has been the attempt to understand rising India’s place in the world.
I can rustle up a mean salad, my oil-less pepper chicken is to die for, and it just takes some beer and rhythm and blues to rock my soul.

























